Guide

W-2 and payroll scams: what a small office should check in January

Reviewed by Alex Rusakovich, Founder ·

January is when payroll staff send Forms W-2, and scammers time their requests to match. Two scams hit small offices. In the W-2 scam, an email that looks like it comes from the owner asks payroll or HR for every employee’s W-2. In payroll diversion, someone pretending to be an employee asks to change where their paycheck goes, or signs in to the employee’s payroll account with a stolen password and changes it there. Both work because they look like normal requests. Set one rule before the season starts: W-2 files are never sent by email on request, and every change to direct deposit is confirmed by phone, using a number you already have. Add multi-factor sign-in to email and payroll accounts, and open the payroll site from a bookmark, not a search. If W-2s already went out, email the IRS at dataloss@irs.gov the same day. If a paycheck went to the wrong account, call the bank right away and ask for a recall.

How does the W-2 scam work?

The IRS describes it this way: the scammer spoofs an email so that it appears to come from an executive of the organization, and sends it to payroll or HR asking for a list of all employees and their Forms W-2 (IRS: Form W-2/SSN data theft). The names and Social Security numbers are then used to file fake tax returns or for other identity theft.

Treat pressure as a warning sign: a request that has to be done today, or that asks you to answer by email instead of calling. Employers have to give employees their Forms W-2 by January 31, so a W-2 request in January doesn’t look odd (IRS: employment tax due dates).

How does payroll diversion work?

The FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3) has warned about three versions:

  • A fake request from an employee. Payroll or HR gets a spoofed email that appears to come from an employee and asks to change their direct deposit account. The new account is often a prepaid card (IC3, 2019).
  • A stolen payroll login. A phishing email captures the employee’s password. The criminal signs in to the payroll account, changes the bank details and adds rules to the employee’s email so they don’t see the change alerts (IC3, 2018).
  • A fake login page in search results. Criminals buy search ads that copy employee self-service sites, with a web address that is one letter off. The employee types their password into the copy, and the criminal changes the direct deposit (IC3, 2025).

Nobody notices until payday, when the employee asks why their pay never arrived.

What should you set up before W-2 season?

  1. Write down one rule: W-2s never go out by email on request. Tell payroll, HR and the office manager in person. The owner should say it too, so nobody worries about refusing a request that seems to come from them.
  2. Confirm every direct deposit change by phone. Call the employee at a number you already have, never one from the email. The IC3 advice is to “use secondary channels or two-factor authentication to verify requests for changes in account information” (IC3, 2019).
  3. Have a second person approve bank detail changes. It takes two minutes and catches a rushed mistake.
  4. Turn on multi-factor sign-in for email and payroll. IC3 recommends two-factor authentication for sensitive systems and separate passwords for payroll (IC3, 2018).
  5. Open the payroll site from a bookmark. Typing the address or using a bookmark avoids fake search ads. IC3 adds a warning worth repeating to staff: “Multi-factor authentication will not protect you if you land on a fraudulent login page” (IC3, 2025).
  6. Block automatic forwarding to outside addresses in Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace, and review mailbox rules for anyone who handles payroll, since a hidden rule can keep change alerts out of sight.
  7. Ask employees to report a missing deposit the same day. Early reports make a bank recall more likely.

What if someone already sent the W-2s?

Act the same day. The IRS asks businesses to:

  1. Email dataloss@irs.gov with “W2 Data Loss” in the subject line. Include the business name, EIN, a contact name and phone number, a short summary of what happened and how many employees are affected. Don’t attach any employee information.
  2. File a complaint with IC3 at ic3.gov.
  3. Email statealert@taxadmin.org to find out how to report the loss to the states.

The same IRS page lists steps for the employees, such as fraud alerts or credit freezes and IRS Publication 5027 on identity theft (IRS: Form W-2/SSN data theft). Tell the employees what happened and what to do, and ask your attorney about notification duties.

Then treat the email account as compromised. Our first-hour phishing checklist covers the password reset, sign-out and mailbox rule checks.

What if the email came in but nobody answered?

Report it. The IRS wants the full email, including the header, so a plain forward isn’t enough. Save the email as a file, attach that file to a new message and send it to phishing@irs.gov with “W2 Scam” in the subject line (IRS: Form W-2/SSN data theft). Then tell staff what the message looked like, so the next one gets spotted.

The same IRS page notes that the IRS doesn’t initiate contact with taxpayers by email, text messages or social media to ask for personal or financial information. An “IRS” email asking for W-2s or bank details is fake.

What if a paycheck went to the wrong account?

  1. Call your bank or payroll provider now and ask for a recall or reversal of the payment. IC3 says to do this as soon as you recognize the fraud (IC3, 2025).
  2. File a complaint at ic3.gov, whatever the amount, and write “payroll diversion” in it (IC3, 2018).
  3. Reset the employee’s email and payroll passwords and check their mailbox for rules that hide alerts.
  4. Change the bank details back only after confirming them with the employee in person or by phone.

Need help?

Our cybersecurity services cover the setup on this page: multi-factor sign-in, forwarding blocks and mailbox rule checks for small offices around Cleveland, Brunswick, Medina and Akron. If something already went wrong, call us at (330) 741-1331 or use our contact page. Ohio businesses can also read our cybersecurity checklist for small Ohio offices, and our free security assessment checks your accounts, sign-in security and email filtering.

More guides and help

Moving offices IT checklist

When to order internet, what to check at the new space, moving day and what to update afterwards.

Learn more

Switching IT providers

What to collect from the old provider, the order to switch in and how to close their access.

Learn more

Windows Server 2016 end of support

What stops on January 12, 2027, how to check your server and the options for a small office.

Learn more

Microsoft 365 plans compared

Business Basic, Standard or Premium: what each Microsoft 365 plan includes, what it costs, and which fits a small office.

Learn more

Ohio cybersecurity checklist

A small-office security checklist and what Ohio’s Data Protection Act says about writing it down.

Learn more

Outsourced vs in-house IT

Hire an IT person, outsource or mix both: costs, trade-offs and a decision checklist.

Learn more

Choosing an IT support company

What to ask, what the contract needs and which red flags to avoid before you sign.

Learn more

Network maintenance checklist

What to check on your office network every month, every quarter and once a year.

Learn more

Moving Microsoft 365 off GoDaddy

How we moved our own Microsoft 365 off GoDaddy without losing email, in the order that works.

Learn more

The first hour after a phishing click

A step-by-step checklist for the hour after someone clicks a bad link.

Learn more

SPF, DKIM and DMARC

The three email records that stop people sending mail in your name.

Learn more

Cybersecurity

Practical protection for your people, devices and data.

Learn more

Get your free assessment

Tell us what you need. We’ll get back to you within 24 hours.

(330) 741-1331 · support@compitservice.com

Scroll to Top