Guide
Outsourced vs in-house IT for a small business
Reviewed by Alex Rusakovich, Founder ·
A small business with 5 to 50 people can hire an IT person, outsource IT to an IT company, or mix the two. An in-house hire knows your office and is in the building when something breaks, but one person rarely covers help for staff, Microsoft 365, security and the network equally well, and the salary is only part of the cost. In the Cleveland metro area, the Bureau of Labor Statistics put average pay for computer user support specialists at $61,400 a year in May 2025, before benefits, paid leave, training and the cost of replacing someone who leaves. An outsourced provider gives you a team for a monthly fee, but only for what the contract covers and at the response times it sets. Many offices mix both: a staff member handles daily requests on site, and a provider handles updates, security, the network and documentation. Whichever you choose, keep the admin accounts in the business’s name.
What are your three options?
- In-house IT: a person on your payroll whose job is IT, full time or as part of a wider role.
- Outsourced IT: an IT company looks after your computers, accounts and network for a monthly fee, mostly remotely, with on-site visits when hands are needed.
- Co-managed IT, sometimes called hybrid: your own person does part of the work and a provider does the rest, under a written split.
Many small offices are really on a fourth option nobody chose: the person who is good with computers. Their real job slips, nothing gets written down, and updates and security settings get done when someone remembers.
What does an in-house IT person really cost?
Start with pay. For the Cleveland, OH metro area in May 2025, the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) reports (BLS: wages for Cleveland, OH):
- Computer user support specialists, the help-desk role: average pay $61,400 a year, median $59,890.
- Network and computer systems administrators, who run the network and the systems behind it: average pay $99,190 a year, median $96,140.
Nationally, the May 2025 averages were $67,330 and $103,680 (BLS: national wages). Those are two different jobs at very different pay. One hire in a small office usually has to do both, plus Microsoft 365 and security.
Then add what sits on top of pay. Nationally, in June 2026, benefits made up 31.5 percent of what private employers spent on full-time workers, and paid leave alone was 8.1 percent (BLS: employer costs for employee compensation). The costs that don’t show on a pay stub:
- Time off. Vacation and sick days are days with no IT cover unless you arrange some.
- Training and tools. Microsoft 365 and security tools change every year, and a provider spreads the cost of support software across many clients. You pay for both for one person.
- Turnover. Recruiting takes the owner’s time, and a good IT person in a small office may leave for a bigger team. Then you hire again.
- One person’s memory. If the passwords, settings and vendor contacts live in one head, a resignation or a long illness can lock the office out of its own systems. The FTC tells businesses to “Terminate their passwords” when someone leaves (FTC: protecting personal information). That is hard when the person leaving is the only one who knows them.
What does outsourced IT really cost?
An IT company usually charges a flat monthly fee based on users or devices, with larger projects quoted separately. You get a team rather than one person, cover when someone is away, and the tools come with the service. The catches are different:
- Scope. The fee covers what the contract lists. An office move or a new phone system is usually billed extra.
- Response times. A provider has other clients. Get response times in writing, split by urgency, and ask what after-hours help costs.
- Distance. A dead switch or a new hire’s desk still needs someone in the room. A provider two hours away is slow on a bad day.
- Knowing your business. An outside team learns your office from notes and tickets, not from walking past desks. Ask to see what they write down.
- Access to your systems. CISA notes that handing more responsibility to a provider “may increase cost-efficiency but could also increase risk exposure,” because its access to your network and data becomes another way in (CISA: risk considerations for MSP customers). Every technician should use a named account with multi-factor sign-in.
What should you keep in-house, and what can you outsource?
CISA suggests small businesses settle three questions with any provider: which tasks the provider takes on, which the business keeps doing, and which are shared. For a small office it usually looks like this.
Keep in-house, always:
- Ownership of the top-level admin accounts for Microsoft 365, your domain name and the firewall, with multi-factor sign-in. Outsiders get their own accounts.
- Decisions on budget, priorities, software and who gets access to what.
- A copy of the documentation, even if someone else writes it.
Usually worth outsourcing:
- Help for staff when a computer, printer or email account stops working.
- Updates and patching, with a check that they installed.
- Microsoft 365 administration: users, licenses and shared mailboxes.
- Security: multi-factor sign-in, endpoint protection, email filtering and alerts for suspicious sign-ins.
- The office network: firewall, switches and Wi-Fi.
Often shared:
- New staff. The office manager orders the laptop and gives the start date; the provider sets up the account and computer.
- First look on site. A staff member checks cables and restarts; the provider takes over remotely or comes in.
- Security training. The provider runs short phishing sessions; the owner makes attendance a requirement.
When does co-managed IT make sense?
Co-managed IT fits when you already have someone, or need someone on site every day, but one person can’t do it all. For example, an office manager who handles daily requests well but has no time for updates and security, or an IT person who is overloaded and needs cover for vacations and projects.
It only works with a written split. CISA’s advice to provider customers is that contracts should “transparently identify ownership of ICT security roles and responsibilities” (CISA: protecting against cyber threats to MSPs and their customers). In plain words: write down who applies updates, who manages multi-factor sign-in, who adds and removes users, and who gets called first. Without that list, each side assumes the other did it.
Which option fits your office?
- Outsourcing usually fits when nobody’s job is IT, your problems are the common ones (computers, email, printers, Wi-Fi, security), and nobody needs to be on site all day.
- An in-house hire starts to make sense when there is a full day of hands-on IT work every day: many staff and devices, software built for your business, or equipment that needs someone in the building. Even then, one hire needs outside help for depth and time off.
- Co-managed fits when you have that person, or plan to hire one, and want a team behind them instead of a single point of failure.
What should you check before you decide?
- List last year’s IT problems and roughly how long each one stopped someone working.
- Count people, computers, locations and the software you can’t run without.
- Estimate how much of the work needs someone in the building, and how often.
- Find out who holds the admin passwords today. If it is one person, fix that first.
- For a hire, price the full cost: pay, benefits, paid leave, training, tools and cover.
- For a provider, get the scope, monthly price, extras and response times in writing.
- Write down which tasks you keep, hand over and share.
- Plan the exit: passwords, documentation and device lists handed back if the person leaves or the contract ends.
If the answers point to outsourcing all or part of your IT, our guide on how to choose an IT support company covers the next step: what to ask on the first call and what the contract needs.
Need help?
Comp IT Service provides outsourced IT support for small offices across Cleveland, Brunswick, Medina and Akron, as your whole IT team or alongside the person you already have. We work with businesses only, from 7 AM to 11 PM every day, and reply to new enquiries within 24 hours. Our free security assessment is a good first step: it looks at your computers, accounts, sign-in security and network, and shows you what we would fix first, so you can see how much IT work your office really has. Call (330) 741-1331, email support@compitservice.com or use our contact page.
More guides and help
Moving offices IT checklist
When to order internet, what to check at the new space, moving day and what to update afterwards.
Learn moreSwitching IT providers
What to collect from the old provider, the order to switch in and how to close their access.
Learn moreWindows Server 2016 end of support
What stops on January 12, 2027, how to check your server and the options for a small office.
Learn moreW-2 and payroll scams
How the W-2 request scam and payroll diversion work, and what a small office should set up before tax season.
Learn moreMicrosoft 365 plans compared
Business Basic, Standard or Premium: what each Microsoft 365 plan includes, what it costs, and which fits a small office.
Learn moreOhio cybersecurity checklist
A small-office security checklist and what Ohio’s Data Protection Act says about writing it down.
Learn moreChoosing an IT support company
What to ask, what the contract needs and which red flags to avoid before you sign.
Learn moreNetwork maintenance checklist
What to check on your office network every month, every quarter and once a year.
Learn moreMoving Microsoft 365 off GoDaddy
How we moved our own Microsoft 365 off GoDaddy without losing email, in the order that works.
Learn moreThe first hour after a phishing click
A step-by-step checklist for the hour after someone clicks a bad link.
Learn moreSPF, DKIM and DMARC
The three email records that stop people sending mail in your name.
Learn moreManaged IT
Day-to-day IT support and upkeep for your office.
Learn moreGet your free assessment
Tell us what you need. We’ll get back to you within 24 hours.