Guide

How to choose an IT support company in Northeast Ohio

Reviewed by Alex Rusakovich, Founder ·

Choosing an IT support company for a small office in Northeast Ohio comes down to five things you can check before you sign. First, write down what you need: help for staff, Microsoft 365 administration, security, the office network and Wi-Fi, and how often someone has to come on site. Second, find out who answers when you call and how fast, and get those response times in writing. Third, make sure your business keeps ownership of its admin accounts, and that the provider signs in through its own named accounts with multi-factor sign-in. Fourth, read the contract for scope, monthly price, security duties and what happens when you leave: passwords, documentation and data handed back. Fifth, agree on a short regular report so you can see the work being done. A provider based near Brunswick, Medina, Cleveland or Akron is also easier to get on site when a problem needs hands at the desk.

What do you actually need from IT support?

Start with a one-page list before you call anyone. Providers price and staff very differently, and a clear list stops you paying for things you don’t use or missing something you do. Most small offices need some mix of these:

  • Help for staff: someone to call when a computer, printer or email account stops working.
  • Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace administration: new users, departing users, licenses, shared mailboxes and sign-in security.
  • Security: multi-factor sign-in, updates, endpoint protection, email filtering and a plan for when someone clicks a phishing link.
  • The office network: firewall, switches, Wi-Fi and the internet connection.
  • New staff and new computers: setting up a laptop so a new person can work on day one.
  • On-site visits: how often someone has to be at your office, and how far they travel to get there.

Add the number of people, computers and locations, and the two or three problems that cost you the most time last year. That last part is the one most offices forget, and it tells a provider more than anything else.

Who answers when you call, and how fast?

Ask exactly what happens when one of your staff has a problem at 8:30 on a Monday morning. Who picks up the phone? Is it the person who will fix it, or someone who logs a ticket and passes it on? How do you reach them after hours, and what does that cost?

Then get the response times in writing, split by urgency: “nobody can work” is different from “one printer is slow”. A provider that won’t put any response time on paper is telling you something.

Ask how far the provider is from your office, too. Plenty of work can be done remotely, but a dead switch or a new hire’s desk set-up still needs someone in the room. For an office in Strongsville or Medina, a provider 20 minutes away and one two hours away are very different on a bad day.

Who should own the admin accounts and passwords?

Your business should. This is the question that matters most and gets asked least.

  • Keep the top-level admin account in your name. For Microsoft 365 that is a global admin account the business controls, with multi-factor sign-in. The provider gets its own accounts, not yours.
  • Named accounts for the provider, with multi-factor sign-in. CISA’s advice to managed service provider customers is to “enforce MFA on MSP accounts that access the customer environment” and to restrict those accounts to the systems the provider manages (CISA: protecting against cyber threats to MSPs and their customers).
  • Only the access the job needs. The FTC’s guidance for small businesses is to give vendors access on a need-to-know basis (FTC: vendor security). If your provider manages your Microsoft 365 through Microsoft’s Partner Center, ask whether it uses granular delegated admin privileges (GDAP), which Microsoft describes as least-privileged, time-bound access that the customer must explicitly grant (Microsoft: GDAP introduction).
  • A record of what they did. CISA also says customers should make sure provider accounts are monitored and audited. In practice, ask whether you can see the sign-in history for their accounts.

If a provider insists on holding the only admin password to your own systems, walk away. Leaving that provider later becomes much harder than it should be.

What should the contract spell out?

A good contract is short, plain and specific. Look for these points:

  1. Scope. What is included in the monthly price, what is billed extra, and at what rate. “All IT” is not a scope.
  2. Who does what. CISA suggests small businesses settle three lists with a provider: which tasks the provider takes on, which the business keeps, and which are shared (CISA: risk considerations for MSP customers).
  3. Security duties. Who applies updates, who manages multi-factor sign-in, who watches for suspicious sign-ins. CISA’s advice is that contracts should “transparently identify ownership of ICT security roles and responsibilities”.
  4. Response times, split by urgency, as above.
  5. Your data. How the provider may use it, and that it is returned or deleted when the contract ends. The FTC’s short version for vendor security is “put it in writing”.
  6. Leaving. Notice period, and a handover list: admin passwords, network diagrams, license lists and any documentation they wrote about your systems.

How do you check the work is being done?

Agree on a short report, monthly or quarterly. One page is enough: updates applied, computers that missed them, who has admin rights, multi-factor sign-in status for every user, and open issues. The FTC tells small businesses to establish a process to confirm vendors are following your rules, rather than taking it on trust (FTC: vendor security).

Before you sign, ask for two references from businesses similar to yours, ideally nearby, and read the provider’s Google reviews. Look for reviews that describe a real problem and how it was handled, not just stars.

What are the red flags?

  • They want to hold the only admin password to your Microsoft 365 or network.
  • Every technician signs in with one shared account.
  • No written scope, or a scope that says “everything”.
  • Pressure to sign a long contract before they have looked at your office.
  • Promises that nothing will ever go wrong. No honest provider says that.
  • They can’t explain a problem or a fix in plain words.

What should you ask on the first call?

  1. Who answers when we call, and who does the work?
  2. What are your response times by urgency, in writing?
  3. How far are you from our office, and how do on-site visits work?
  4. Will our business keep ownership of the admin accounts?
  5. Do your technicians use their own named accounts with multi-factor sign-in?
  6. What exactly is in the monthly price, and what is billed extra?
  7. What report do we get, and how often?
  8. What happens to our passwords, documentation and data if we leave?
  9. Can we speak to two businesses like ours that you support?
  10. What would you fix first in our office, and why?

Need help?

Comp IT Service supports small offices across Cleveland, Brunswick, Medina and Akron with managed IT services, Microsoft 365 support and cybersecurity. Bring this list to the first call and ask us every question on it. Our free security assessment is a good first step: it looks at your accounts, sign-in security and network, and shows you what we would fix first. Call (330) 741-1331, email support@compitservice.com or use our contact page.

More guides and help

Moving offices IT checklist

When to order internet, what to check at the new space, moving day and what to update afterwards.

Learn more

Switching IT providers

What to collect from the old provider, the order to switch in and how to close their access.

Learn more

Windows Server 2016 end of support

What stops on January 12, 2027, how to check your server and the options for a small office.

Learn more

W-2 and payroll scams

How the W-2 request scam and payroll diversion work, and what a small office should set up before tax season.

Learn more

Microsoft 365 plans compared

Business Basic, Standard or Premium: what each Microsoft 365 plan includes, what it costs, and which fits a small office.

Learn more

Ohio cybersecurity checklist

A small-office security checklist and what Ohio’s Data Protection Act says about writing it down.

Learn more

Outsourced vs in-house IT

Hire an IT person, outsource or mix both: costs, trade-offs and a decision checklist.

Learn more

Network maintenance checklist

What to check on your office network every month, every quarter and once a year.

Learn more

Moving Microsoft 365 off GoDaddy

How we moved our own Microsoft 365 off GoDaddy without losing email, in the order that works.

Learn more

The first hour after a phishing click

A step-by-step checklist for the hour after someone clicks a bad link.

Learn more

SPF, DKIM and DMARC

The three email records that stop people sending mail in your name.

Learn more

Managed IT

Day-to-day IT support and upkeep for your office.

Learn more

Get your free assessment

Tell us what you need. We’ll get back to you within 24 hours.

(330) 741-1331 · support@compitservice.com

Scroll to Top